There’s a new attack out there which is getting quite a lot of attention this week. It’s called Thunderspy, and it uses the Thunderbolt port which is on many modern laptops and other computers to suck data from your machine. I thought that it might be a good issue to cover this week, as although it’s a nasty attack, there are easy ways to defend yourself, some of which I’ve already covered in previous articles, as they’re generally good security practice to follow.
What is Thunderspy?
Thunderspy is an attack on your computer which allows an attacker with moderate resources to get at your data under certain circumstances. The attacker needs:
- physical access to your machine – not for long (maybe five minutes), but they do need it. This type of attack is sometimes called an “evil maid” attack, as it can be carried out by hotel staff with access to your room;
- the ability to take your computer apart (a bit) – all we’re talking here is a screwdriver;
- a little bit of hardware – around $400 worth, according to one source;
- access to some freely available software;
- access to another computer at the same time.
There’s one more thing that the attacker needs, and that’s for you to leave your computer on, or in suspend mode. I’ve discussed different power modes before (in 3 laptop power mode options), and mentioned, as well, that leaving your machine in suspend mode is generally a bad idea (in 7 security tips for travelling with your laptop). It turns out I was right.
What’s the bad news?
Well, there’s quite a lot of bad news:
- lots of machines have Thunderbolt ports (you can find pictures of both the port and connectors on Wikipedia’s Thunderbolt page, in case you’re not sure whether your machine is affected);
- machines are vulnerable even if you have full disk encryption;
- Windows machines are vulnerable;
- Linux machines are vulnerable;
- Macintosh machines are vulnerable;
- most machines with a Thunderbolt port from 2011 onwards are vulnerable;
- although protection is available on some newer machines (from around 2019)
- the extent of its efficacy is unclear;
- lots of manufacturers don’t implement it;
- some protections that you can turn on break USB and other functionality;
- one variant of the attack breaks Thunderbolt security permanently, meaning that the attacker won’t need to take your computer apart at all for subsequent attacks: they just need physical access to the port whilst your machine it turned on (or in suspend mode).
The worst thing to note is that full disk encryption does not help you if your computer is turned on or in suspend mode.
Note – I’ve been unable to find out whether any Chromebooks have Thunderbolt support. Please check your model’s specifications or datasheet to be certain.
What’s the good news?
The good news is short and sweet: if you turn your computer completely off, or ensure that it’s in Hibernate mode, then it’s not vulnerable. Thunderspy is a nasty attack, but it’s easily prevented.
What should I do?
- Turn your computer off when you leave it unattended, even for short amounts of time.
That was easy, wasn’t it? This is best practice anyway, and it turns out that hibernate mode is also OK. What the attacker is looking for is a powered-up, logged-on computer with Thunderbolt. If you can stop them finding a computer that meets those criteria, then you’re fine. Putting your computer into hibernate mode is also OK.