Enarx for everyone (a quest)

In your backpack, the only tool that you have to protect you is Enarx…

You are stuck in a deep, dark wood, with spooky noises and roots that seem to move and trip you up.  Behind every tree malevolent eyes look out at you.  You look in your backpack and realise that the only tool that you have for your protection is Enarx, the trusty open source project given you by the wizened old person at the beginning of your quest.  Hard as you try, you can’t remember what it does, or how to use it.  You realise that now is that time to find out.

What do you do next?

  • If you are a business person, go to 1. Why I need Enarx to reduce business risk.
  • If you are an architect, go to 2. How I can use Enarx to protect sensitive data.
  • If you are a techy, go to 3. Tell me more about Enarx technology (I can take it).

1. Why I need Enarx to reduce business risk

You are the wise head upon which your business relies to consider and manage risk.  One of the problems that you run into is that you have sensitive data that needs to be protected.  Financial data, customer data, legal data, payroll data: it’s all at risk of compromise if it’s not adequately protected.  Who can you trust, however?  You want to be able to use public clouds, but the risks of keeping and processing information on systems which are not under your direct control are many and difficult to quantify.  Even your own systems are vulnerable to outdated patches, insider attacks or compromises: confidentiality is difficult to ensure, but vital to your business.

Enarx is a project which allows you to run applications in the public cloud, on your premises – or wherever else – with significantly reduced and better quantifiable risk.  It uses hardware-based security called “Trust Execution Environments” from CPU manufacturers, and cuts out many of the layers that can be compromised.  The only components that do need to be trusted are fully open source software, which means that they can be examined and audited by industry experts and your own teams.

Well done: you found out about Enarx.  Continue to 6. Well, what’s next?

2. How I can use Enarx to protect sensitive data

You are the expert architect who has to consider the best technologies and approaches for your organisation.  You worry about where best to deploy sensitive applications and data, given the number of layers in the stack that may have been compromised, and the number of entities – human and machine – that have the opportunity to peek into or mess with the integrity of your applications.  You can’t control the public cloud, nor know exactly what the stack it’s running is, but equally, the resources required to ensure that you can run sufficient numbers of hardened systems on premises are growing.

Enarx is an open source project which uses TEEs (Trusted Execution Environments), to allow you to run applications within “Keeps” on systems that you don’t trust.  Enarx manages the creation of these Keeps, providing cryptographic confidence that the Keeps are using valid CPU hardware and then encrypting and provisioning your applications and data to the Keep using one-time cryptographic keys.  Your applications run without any of the layers in the stack (e.g. hypervisor, kernel, user-space, middleware) being able to look into the Keep.  The Keep’s run-time can accept applications written in many different languages, including Rust, C, C++, C#, Go, Java, Python and Haskell.  It allows you to run on TEEs from various CPU manufacturers without having to worry about portability: Enarx manages that for you, along with attestation and deployment.

Well done: you found out about Enarx.  Continue to 6. Well, what’s next?

3. Tell me more about Enarx technology (I can take it)

You are a wily developer with technical skills beyond the ken of most of your peers.  A quick look at the github pages tells you more: Enarx is an open source project to allow you to deploy and applications within TEEs (Trusted Execution Environments).

  • If you’d like to learn about how to use Enarx, proceed to 4. I want to use Enarx.
  • If you’d like to learn about contributing to the Enarx project, proceed to 5. I want to contribute to Enarx.

Well done: you found out about Enarx.  Continue to 6. Well, what’s next?

4. I want to use Enarx

You learn good news: Enarx is designed to be easy to use!

If you want to run applications that process sensitive data, or which implement sensitive algorithms themselves, Enarx is for you.  Enarx is a deployment framework for applications, rather than a development framework.  What this means is that you don’t have to write to particular SDKs, or manage the tricky attestation steps required to use TEEs.  You write your application in your favourite language, and as long as it has WebAssembly as a compile target, it should run within an Enarx “Keep”.  Enarx even manages portability across hardware platforms, so you don’t need to worry about that, either.  It’s all open source, so you can look at it yourself, audit it, or even contribute (if you’re interested in that, you might want to proceed to 5. I want to contribute to Enarx).

Well done: you found out about Enarx.  Continue to 6. Well, what’s next?

5. I want to contribute to Enarx

Enarx is an open source project (under the Apache 2.0 licence), and we welcome contributions, whether you are a developer, tester, documentation guru or other enthusiastic bod with an interest in providing a way for the rest of the world to up the security level of the applications they’re running with minimal effort.  There are various components to Enarx, including attestation, hypervisor work, uni-kernel and WebAssembly run-time pieces.  We want to provide a simple and flexible framework to allow developers and operations folks to deploy applications to TEEs on any supported platform without recompilation, having to choose an obscure language or write to a particular SDK.  Please have a look around our github site and get in touch if you’re in a position to contribute.

Well done: you found out about Enarx.  Continue to 6. Well, what’s next?

6. Well, what’s next?

You now know enough to understand how Enarx can help you: well done!  At time of writing, Enarx is still in development, but we’re working hard to make it available to all.

We’ve known for a long time that we need encryption for data at rest and in transit: Enarx helps you do encryption for data in use.

For more information, you may wish to visit:


うまくいけば、この記事は2019年のボストンでのRed Hat Summitのデモに合わせて、投稿されるはずです。

同僚のNathaniel McCallumが行うデモはEnarxを早期具体化したものです。Enarxはここ数ヶ月Red Hatで私たち数名が行ってきたプロジェクトで、世界に公表する準備ができました。コードがあり、デモがあり、GitHubのレポジトリがあり、ロゴもあります。他にはプロジェクトとして何が必要でしょうか。

















TEE(Trusted Execution Environments https://aliceevebob.com/2019/02/26/oh-how-i-love-my-tee-or-do-i/ 参照)を使って、以下のようなアーキテクチャに似たものを提供する予定です。





最初のコードは公開されていて、(この時点ではAMDのSEV TEEで動きます)皆さんにお知らせできる程度には動きます。



一番簡単な方法は Enarx github https://github.com/enarx をチェックすることです。








2019年5月7日 Mike Bursell


Announcing Enarx


If I’ve managed the process properly, this article should be posting at almost exactly the time that we show a demo at Red Hat Summit 2019 in Boston.  That demo, to be delivered by my colleague Nathaniel McCallum, will be of an early incarnation of Enarx, a project that a few of us at Red Hat have been working on for a few months now, and which we’re ready to start announcing to the world.  We have code, we have a demo, we have a github repository, we have a logo: what more could a project want?  Well, people – but we’ll get to that.

What’s the problem?

When you run software (a “workload”) on a system (a “host”) on the cloud or on your own premises, there are lots and lots of layers.  You often don’t see those layers, but they’re there.  Here’s an example of the layers that you might see in a standard cloud virtualisation architecture.  The different colours represent different entities that “own”  different layers or sets of layers.


Here’s a similar diagram depicting a standard cloud container architecture.  As before, each different colour represents a different “owner” of a layer or set of layers.


These owners may be of very different types, from hardware vendors to OEMs to Cloud Service Providers (CSPs) to middleware vendors to Operating System vendors to application vendors to you, the workload owner.  And for each workload that you run, on each host, the exact list of layers is likely to be different.  And even when they’re the same, the versions of the layers instances may be different, whether it’s a different BIOS version, a different bootloader, a different kernel version or whatever else.

Now, in many contexts, you might not worry about this and your Cloud Service Provider goes out of its way to abstract these layers and their version details away from you.  But this is a security blog, for security people, and that means that anybody who’s reading this probably does care.

The reason we care is not just the different versions and the different layers, but the number of different things – and different entities – that we need to trust if we’re going to be happy running any sort of sensitive workload on these types of stacks.  I need to trust every single layer, and the owner of every single layer, not only to do what they say they will do, but also not to be compromised.  This is a big stretch when it comes to running my sensitive workloads.

What’s Enarx?

Enarx is a project which is trying to address this problem of having to trust all of those layers.  We made the decision that we wanted to allow people running workloads to be able to reduce the number of layers – and owners – that they need to trust to the absolute minimum.  We plan to use Trusted Execution Environments (“TEEs” – see Oh, how I love my TEE (or do I?)), and to provide an architecture that looks a little more like this:


In a world like this, you have to trust the CPU and firmware, and you need to trust some middleware – of which Enarx is part – but you don’t need to trust all of the other layers, because we will leverage the capabilities of the TEE to ensure the integrity and confidentiality of your application.  The Enarx project will provide attestation of the TEE, so that you know you’re running on a true and trusted TEE, and will provide open source, auditable code to help you trust the layer directly beneath you application.

The initial code is out there – working on AMD’s SEV TEE at the moment – and enough of it works now that we’re ready to tell you about it.

Making sure that your application meets your own security requirements is down to you.  🙂

How do I find out more?

Easiest is to visit the Enarx github: https://github.com/enarx.

We’ll be adding more information there – it’s currently just code – but bear with us: there are only a few of us on the project at the moment. A blog is on the list of things we’d like to have, but I thought I’d start here for now.

We’d love to have people in the community getting involved in the project.  It’s currently quite low-level, and requires quite a lot of knowledge to get running, but we’ll work on that.  You will need some specific hardware to make it work, of course.  Oh, and if you’re an early boot or a low-level kvm hacker, we’re particularly interested in hearing from you.

I will, of course, respond to comments on this article.